Looking for the best places to eat in the Florida Keys? You’re in the right place. The Keys have no shortage of mouthwatering eateries with menu choices that can satisfy any palate. Whether you’re in the mood for modern American eats or want to sample the local seafood fare, the Florida Key is where you’ll find some of the tastiest grub in America. Are you on vacation or planning to move to the Keys? Either way, it doesn’t matter. Once you get here, be sure to check out our favorite Florida Key restaurants.
Our top choice for best restaurant in the Florida Keys is Pierre’s Restaurant & Morada Bay Beach Café. Opened in 1999, the popular dining establishment sits in a two-story plantation house that mimics old style colonials found in West Africa. However, once you walk in the front door, you’ll be amazed at how the interiors reflect cultures from all over the world. The restaurant has several areas to visit, including The Green Flash Lounge downstairs which features a mahogany bar and beige banquettes. Upstairs, the dining room is adorned with interesting African, Indian, and Moroccan artifacts.
Pierre’s is located in the heart of Islamorada with a backdrop of a palm tree-lined beach, giving diners a magnificent view of the Florida Bay. Guests may choose to enjoy their meals indoors in the fine dining room or outdoors on the veranda. No matter where you choose to sit, you’re sure to enjoy the exotic menu featuring French Fusion cuisine. Every dish is made fresh with the highest quality ingredients delivered daily from all over the world. From Margez lamb sausage to Hawaiian bigeye tuna, you’ll sit in awe as you devour every last bite.
Located in Key West, Bien is a frequented eatery that serves authentic Caribbean and Latino food in a laid-back environment. Bien has been featured in TLC, Travel Channel, and Esquire, and is a 2014 Trip Advisor Winner earning a Certificate of Excellence. On the menu you’ll find a variety of options, ranging from sandwiches served on lightly toasted baguettes to filling entrees like succulent roasted pork shoulder, delicate slices of mahi, and peeled and deveined black tiger prawns. Bien now also serves beer and wine. The restaurant is open Tuesday through Saturday.
The Square Grouper Bar & Grill in Cudjoe Key is your source for delicious American and seafood classics. The Lower Keys establishment is also vegetarian-friendly. The environmentally-friendly restaurant uses all “green” paper products and straws derived from corn products. The innovative menu will have you asking for more, as each bite is better than the last. At Square Grouper you’ll find a large selection of small plates, as well as specials that are constantly changing and homemade desserts. The restaurant also offers an extensive wine list in addition to microbrews. Stop in for lunch, dinner, dessert, or cocktails. Also check out the gluten-free menu.
Prime Steakhouse in Key West offers American fare and seafood in an upscale dining establishment. Since opening in 2005, the restaurant has quickly become the Florida Key’s premier steakhouse. Its signature dish is its prime beef which is cooked to perfection at nearly 1,000 degrees Fahrenheit. Every dish is prepared under the close supervision of an executive chef, ensuring tender cuts of meats, tasty appetizers, and plenty of other delicacies. From the nightly pasta specials to the daily fresh fish options, you’re sure to find something you like on the extensive menu. Reserve a table by calling the restaurant or on their website.
In Marathon you’ll find the Butterfly Café, a vegetarian-friendly restaurant serving up both American cuisine and seafood. Dinner at the Butterfly Café, which can be found inside the Tranquility Bay Beachfront Hotel & Resort, is served each night from 6 PM to 9 PM. Enjoy your meal in the lavish dining room or step out onto the covered patio. You’ll find a wide variety of dishes on the menu to choose, such as the Horseradish Encrusted Florida Grouper, Tropical Crab Cakes, and Florida Keys’ Shrimp Cocktail.
Another popular Key West restaurant is Garbo’s Grill. The eatery specializes in American, Korean, and Caribbean cuisine with people-pleasers like tacos, burritos, hot dogs, and burgers. However, these are not your ordinary eats. Try a taco with habanero glazed shrimp or a hot dog wrapped in Applewood bacon and topped with mango, jalapeno, onion, and house-made Caribbean sauce. The owners of Garbo’s started off as vacationers in the Florida Keys and after just a few visits fell in love with the islands. Today, they own a restaurant directly on Caroline Street. You’ll know you’ve found the place where you see the Attack-Van parked out front.
When it comes to dessert, there’s no better place than the Key Plaza Creperie in Key West. Serving breakfast and lunch all day, there’s no better place to come and enjoy a French press coffee, mug of tea, or fresh made crepe. The establishment also offers great grab-and-go meals, such as wraps and paninis. The Key Plaza Creperie has remained a favorite by both locals and tourists alike due to their highly appetizing eats and relaxing ambiance. The restaurant even won a Certificate of Excellence by Trip Advisor in 2015.
Are you hungry? Reserve a table at one of numerous top restaurants throughout the Florida Keys. These eateries have thousands of five-star reviews and tens of thousands of satisfied customers. Best of all, you can find dining establishments at all price points. Whether you’re just looking for a quick bite to eat on your lunch break or want to sit down for a three course meal, you’ll find exactly what you’re looking for in the Florida Keys. If you have yet to try any of these top restaurants, be sure to stop by the next time you’re visiting the Keys.